Dexter: Original Sin, the prequel spin-off, focuses on the early life of the titular antihero and his journey to becoming the avenging serial killer that viewers fell in love with in the original Showtime series. And the show has opened new possibilities for the franchise’s redemption after the disappointing sequel, New Blood.

It received criticism for several things, including the lack of traditional Dexter elements along with its controversial ending. However, with Original Sin Season 2 potentially on the way, the franchise could restore fans’ faith, especially with the nostalgic approach and Michael C. Hall’s significant involvement.
Dexter: Original Sin could redeem New Blood and bring fans home again
When Dexter: New Blood ended, I, like many other fans, was left with mixed emotions. Though the return of our favorite morally ambiguous serial killer had its moments, let’s be honest, the ending left many of us disappointed.
Now with Dexter: Original Sin diving into the early years of Dexter Morgan, I was cautiously optimistic. After hearing what the creator of the show potentially has in store for Season 2, I might just be ready to forgive the disaster that New Blood was.

One comment from the creator Clyde Phillips’ recent interview with ComicBook struck me, when he said, “It’ll be like coming home for the audience.” That’s a bold promise, especially considering the last time we ‘came home’ to Dexter, it ended in controversy.
Phillips also teased that the potential Season 2, though not yet officially renewed, will follow young Dexter’s transformation into ‘America’s favorite serial killer.’
He said,
It will become the biggest Easter egg in the world. We need to see him grow in several ways. [He’ll] have to learn how to blend better. He will have to learn how to kill better and more efficiently.
Clyde Phillips also teased a slow but deliberate buildup of classic Dexter traits, saying, “So, next season, does he get his boat? Does he get his apartment? Does he start wearing the Henley? Does he start doing the red string thing? Those are things that we’re going to explore.“

These are the details that matter, as they are not just visual easter eggs but rather are essential parts of Dexter’s identity. Introducing them piece by piece makes Original Sin a prequel series that feels much more like a genuine extension of the original series rather than just another spin-off.
Micheal C. Hall has a crucial role in bringing nostalgia to Dexter: Original Sin
Among all the new potential additions to the spin-off series, the biggest game-changer could be Michael C. Hall’s involvement. Following the events of New Blood, Dexter: Original Sin features Hall briefly before diving into his early life.
However, his presence doesn’t stop there, Hall narrates Dexter’s inner monologue throughout the series. In his interview with ComicBook, showrunner Clyde Phillips describes his involvement as “crucial to the show,” which tells me one thing, we’re getting that classic Dexter Morgan narration back.

Though opinions on the classic element of the series have been divisive, if you’re a Dexter fan, you know how important that internal monologue is. It wasn’t just an exposition, it was the heart and soul of the show.
Having Hall’s voice guide us through Dexter’s early years will be the glue that ties Original Sin to the original series. It will help longtime fans feel like they’re truly watching the same character evolve, even as Patrick Gibson embodies the character in the spin-off.
Why plans for Dexter: Original Sin Season 2 might just redeem New Blood?
Let’s be real, Dexter: New Blood left a sour taste for many fans. Though it had potential, it never quite felt like Dexter at its best. However, the potential Season 2 of Dexter: Original Sin has a shot at making up for the sequel.

By bringing back the classic elements that made the original show work, including voice-overs, signature details, and the slow transformation of Dexter, it gives us what we really wanted, a deep dive into the mind of our favorite antihero.
And Season 2, which is believed to be renewed anytime soon given the positive response to the series, Original Sin might just heal the wounds of New Blood if they stick to the plan.
All the Dexter series are available to watch on Paramount+.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire