Taylor Sheridan isn’t one to hold back, but 1923 season 2 might’ve just crossed the line. The Yellowstone prequel’s been known for its brutal storytelling, but this time, it’s got fans fuming. One of its episodes delivered a scene so vile that it’s making even the most die-hard viewers question if Sheridan knows when to quit.
With shocking violence and misery, the show keeps doubling down on its darkest elements. But instead of deepening the story, it’s starting to feel like suffering for suffering’s sake.
When drama drags: 1923 season 2 tests fans’ patience with its most extreme plot yet
Taylor Sheridan’s never been afraid to push boundaries, but 1923 season 2 just took stuff to whole new levels. One scene was pretty brutal. And speaking truly ten, some of these plot choices are starting to feel like filler in a high school essay that’s desperately trying to hit the word count.
Take Spencer. The man’s basically Superman at this point, effortlessly handling life-threatening situations like it’s just another Tuesday. But waiting to confront those guys who literally threatened a child? Then jumping off a moving train after securing his safety? It’s the kind of logic that makes you pause and go, “Wait, what?”
1923 Season 2: Taylor Sheridan’s Poor Writing For Two Characters Is Ruining Yellowstone’s Grand Saga
And the good doctor, though? Guess he’s just a permanent Dutton now. No home. No life outside the ranch. Just another character stuck in the never-ending chaos of 1923. One Redditor put it best:
Then there’s the Native American subplot, which, at this point, feels like an entirely different show. No connection to the main story, and no clear direction — just extra screen time that has some fans reaching for the fast-forward button.
Maybe it will all come together. But right now, it’s testing patience.
Fans call out 1923 season 2 for repetitive plot and excessive violence
Some scenes go too far, and fans are calling it out. 1923 Season 2’s brutality, especially in Teona’s arc, feels excessive. Many believe certain moments add nothing to the narrative and should’ve been left out.
Beyond that, the show’s structure is wearing thin. Every episode follows the same predictable beats – Spencer fights, Alex struggles to be taken seriously, Jacob and Cara stand strong, Teona keeps running, and the villains plot evil schemes. The repetition is making it hard to stay engaged.
Despite the frustration, the show remains oddly addictive. Even those who find it over the top can’t seem to look away. Sheridan may be losing his grip, but 1923 still has viewers hooked.
Watch 1923 on Paramount Plus & Apple TV.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire
