On paper, The Alto Knights looked like a certified mob movie banger. Robert De Niro in two roles? Check. Legendary director Barry Levinson at the helm? Check. Real-life mob drama set in gritty New York? Double check. It had all the makings of a gangster epic that could walk into theaters, collect its box office cash, and strut out like a made man. But instead, it tripped over its own loafers.
The film barely made a dent in its opening weekend, grossing just $3 million against a whopping $50 million budget. And while Snow White tiptoed in with a soft debut, it still managed to leave The Alto Knights sleeping with the fishes in sixth place. Yikes. So what happened? How did a film with this much pedigree end up getting iced at the box office? Let’s just say there were more than a few missteps along the way.
Buckle up, because we’re about to dig into all the behind-the-scenes chaos, misfires, and head-scratching decisions that helped this wise guy flick whiff harder than a mobster trying to play nice in court.
5. Critics and crowds were anything but killer
Turns out, critics and audiences weren’t exactly rolling out the red carpet for The Alto Knights. Instead, they kind of gave it the side-eye and kept it moving. The film pulled in a lukewarm B CinemaScore from opening day crowds, which, in the movie, basically means “we didn’t hate it, but we’re not telling our friends either.”
And with a Rotten Tomatoes score stuck at a sad 38%, it’s clear that neither Costello nor Genovese made enough of an impression to win over the critics. One reviewer even roasted the film for endlessly talking about mob life instead of showing it. Yikes.
And poor Robert De Niro, fresh off an Oscar-nominated turn in Killers of the Flower Moon gets dragged down in a script that spends more time monologuing than making moves. After coming from the prestige of Martin Scorsese to this? That’s like trading a vintage wine for boxed grape juice. In a world where word of mouth can make or break a movie, The Alto Knights talked a big game and audiences responded with a collective shrug.
4. The Alto Knights release date didn’t do any favors
The Alto Knights hit theaters on March 21, the same day as Disney’s highly anticipated live-action remake of Snow White. While the audiences for these two films are obviously different, releasing a slow-paced, old-school mob drama alongside a family-friendly fantasy movie wasn’t exactly a strategic move. When a big studio film like Snow White debuts, even with modest expectations, it tends to dominate headlines, marketing space, and general audience attention.
In short, The Alto Knights got buried. Then there’s the spring break crowd looking for lighter fare, and a serious, dialogue-heavy crime saga never stood a chance. Timing matters, especially when you’re not a tentpole or part of a franchise. A later spring or early fall release could’ve given it more breathing room, and maybe even a better shot at success.
But March? That’s a strange slot for a film that leans heavily on nostalgia, period accuracy, and slow-burn storytelling. Instead of standing out, it got lost in the shuffle. For a movie that wanted to feel timeless, its timing couldn’t have been worse.
3. Did you see The Alto Knight promoting?
Let’s be honest, did anyone even know this movie was coming out? The Alto Knights suffered from one of the biggest sins in modern movie marketing, invisibility. There was no buzz, no viral campaign, no trailer that got people talking. Even on social media, where studios often drum up anticipation weeks in advance, The Alto Knights was eerily quiet.
Considering it stars Robert De Niro and is directed by Barry Levinson, that lack of promotion is baffling. This isn’t a no-name indie release, it’s a $50 million studio project. And yet, it showed up in theaters without so much as a whisper. For casual moviegoers, it was basically a surprise drop, except not the cool kind like Beyoncé does.
Marketing makes or breaks a film’s opening weekend, especially when it’s not part of a built-in franchise or doesn’t have Marvel-level hype. Without trailers, interviews, or social buzz to stir up interest, The Alto Knights failed to create any momentum going into the release. If a movie hits theaters and no one hears about it, does it even exist? In this case, not really. The studio’s silence was deafening, and the box office returns reflected that.
2. Robert De Niro’s dual role felt gimmick
Robert De Niro playing two real-life mob bosses sounds like a brilliant idea on paper but in execution? It felt like a gimmick. He plays both Frank Costello and Vito Genovese, two key figures in the American mafia scene, but the movie doesn’t do enough to make them feel distinct or necessary as dual performances. Without clear visual or narrative differences between the two, the whole thing felt more like a stunt than a meaningful choice.
Audiences weren’t impressed. Instead of marveling at De Niro’s range, many found it distracting and even confusing at times. It’s hard to connect with the story when you’re constantly reminded that you’re watching the same actor try to be two different people in the same movie.
It also didn’t help that the script didn’t give him much to work with. The characters lacked depth, and the storytelling didn’t dig deep enough into their psychological or emotional conflicts. So what could’ve been a powerhouse showcase for De Niro just ended up being odd. In the end, the dual role didn’t elevate the film, it just made people wish they were watching Goodfellas instead.
1. Box office numbers were a disaster
When a movie costs $50 million to make and only pulls in $3 million during its opening weekend, we’re not talking about a stumble, we’re talking about a full-blown flop. The Alto Knights didn’t just underperform; it crashed hard. It couldn’t even crack the Top 5 in its debut, landing at No. 6 behind films with smaller budgets and less star power.
The box office is often about momentum. If a movie opens low but has strong legs, it can survive. But with The Alto Knights, there was no such hope. The dismal opening sent a clear signal: audiences weren’t interested. With a projected total well below its budget, it’s clear the movie won’t be recouping its costs anytime soon, if ever.
This also marks Warner Bros.’ second major misfire in a row, following the expensive sci-fi flop Mickey 17. That kind of track record shakes studio confidence and puts even big names like De Niro in an awkward position. While streaming might offer a second life, it’s clear the film’s theatrical run is DOA. No matter how talented the cast or how iconic the genre is, bad box office math doesn’t lie.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire
