We’ve always believed that a good story should be like a finely tuned orchestra—every note harmonizing perfectly. But in the case of 1923 Season 2, it feels like Taylor Sheridan might have handed the baton to the wrong conductor.
Sure, the Spencer-Alexandra storyline is filled with drama, hardship, and intense moments, but isn’t that just a small cog in the larger wheel of what 1923 fans truly crave? After all, it’s the Dutton family dynamic that makes us tick. Right?
We’re not just tuning in for Spencer and Alexandra’s seemingly never-ending journey to Montana. What we want to see is an unfiltered interaction between the Duttons once they’re on the ranch. Sheridan’s obsession with their reunion could leave little room to explore the deeper familial ties, and that’s a tragedy.
Spencer and Alexandra’s long trek: Fans are yearning for more Dutton family bonds in 1923
Ah, let’s be real: The Spencer-Alexandra trek is starting to feel like watching paint dry. Yes, they’re overcoming obstacles, but it’s dragging on. Fans are growing restless, wanting more than just their saga. What makes 1923 stand out are those moments where the Duttons are grappling with the harsh realities of life in Montana. The real heart of the show lies in the relationships—how Spencer’s love for his family intersects with the legacy of the ranch. Isn’t it about time we see more of that?
Take a step back and ask yourself: When was the last time 1923 made you feel the Dutton family bond? For many of us, it’s not Spencer’s dramatic journey we’re yearning for—it’s more of Cara’s wisdom, Jacob’s leadership, and the raw, unspoken connections that breathe life into this show. One fan summed it up perfectly:
Comment
byu/LakesideNorth from discussion
in1923Series
This fan is saying they really want to see more of the deep connection between Cara and Spencer. They feel there’s obviously a lot of “heart” between the two and that their bond is something special. If Taylor Sheridan doesn’t capitalize on these deeply emotional exchanges, the heart of 1923 will feel hollow.
Let’s see what fans are saying:
Comment
byu/LakesideNorth from discussion
in1923Series
Comment
byu/LakesideNorth from discussion
in1923Series
Comment
byu/LakesideNorth from discussion
in1923Series
Comment
byu/LakesideNorth from discussion
in1923Series
The truth? We think Sheridan’s misstep is in the pacing. By spending so much time on Spencer and Alexandra’s quest, the emotional core of the Dutton family is getting sidelined.
Alex’s journey: A mother’s love and unyielding fight for survival in 1923 S2
They say that “the road to the heart is always a rough one,” and if there’s one person who embodies this sentiment, it’s Alex, the character Julia Schlaepfer breathes life into in 1923 season 2. Watching her traverse the emotional and physical turmoil of her journey—fleeing her past, carrying a child, and enduring unimaginable challenges—it’s impossible not to feel the weight of her determination.
Alex’s story is not just about a woman fleeing her past or trying to find love. It’s about survival against all odds and finding purpose in the face of adversity. The emotional weight of her journey to Ellis Island is something that Schlaepfer feels deeply. The actor was quick to sign on, as she saw it as an incredible opportunity to bring a real and visceral story to life. But it wasn’t just about playing a character; it was about understanding the struggles faced by so many people throughout history.
When Taylor Sheridan approached Schlaepfer about the medical examination scene, he was upfront. Schlaepfer agreed, seeing the deeper value in telling this difficult story (via PEOPLE):
He was like, ‘I really want to write this episode, but I want to make sure, as an actor, you are okay with going through that, because it will be very traumatic.’
However, when it came to filming the sequence, she admitted, “It was really brutal.” Filming the scene lasted for hours, and it was emotionally taxing for Schlaepfer. Despite the exhaustion, she said
I was taken such good care of, but still, it was hard to shake.
For Alex, the love she has for her unborn child is what keeps her going. As Schlaepfer has beautifully put it:
It’s no longer just [for] Spencer. She’s creating life, and I think you really see her go through the deepest, most beautiful parts of what a mother’s love can endure.
The love a mother has for her child is one of the most powerful forces in the world, and in Alex’s case, it’s what fuels her journey, no matter how painful or difficult. Her commitment to Spencer and their child becomes the compass by which she navigates every trial that comes her way.
1923 season 2 is streaming on Paramount+.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire
